Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: READ BEFORE POSTING - Music Discussion Guidelines
Smosh Forums > General > Music Discussion
Pages: 1, 2, 3
dusty
What should your band thread look like? Here is a good example.

Attention All Music Forum Posters
I'm redoing the rules so they're easier to understand and quicker to read. The original rules can be viewed in the spoiler at the end of this post.


-In any thread, DO NOT repeat something that is either common knowledge or has been said in recent posts. For instance, do not post "Jimi Hendx pwns all!" in the Greatest Guitarist thread. It becomes spam if everyone's posts are the same.


-You can make a thread about any genre or band.

-We already have Favorite song/artist/album/etc threads, so don't make them

-For the descriptions of band threads, please put the bands genre.

-Link to the bands MySpace, or their official website (if it has music samples) Additionally linked youtube videos are also a good idea. This is the most important rule, as this helps people who don't know about the band listen to their music. Failure to include information about a band will result in the thread being deleted/closed.

-A thread is open for discussion about anything regarding the topic. People can express both positive and negative opinions about a band.

-Don't make polls comparing two or more bands. No exceptions (besides the ones that already exist).

-Don't make polls asking which genre is better.

-Keep the spamming at a minimal

-Do not create a thread for your favorite band, genre, etc. All of these threads have been created.

-Failure to follow these rules will result in warnings and/or bans.

Hopefully you will read these rules and help me make the music forum a better place and more fun for all. If you still have any questions regarding the rules, refer to this good example: (Link).



Original Music Forum Guidelines:

[spoiler]There will be specific guidelines for this forum that all must follow.


- You're allowed to make a thread about any band you want that doesnt already have its own thread, as long as you provide a good foundation for discussion in this thread. Please post a link to mp3's/myspace so that people who have not heard the band/music can hear it and make their opinions on it. From now on if a generally unknown band is posted with just asking what people think, then that 1) thread will be closed/deleted and 2) the poster will be warned.

- Also, don't make a thread simply asking if people like a certain band. A thread with this question will result in people saying, "Yeah, I like them" or "No, I don't" which really isn't a discussion at all.

- It is highly encouraged to spread the word of local, or lesser-known bands, as much as possible, but please refer to the bullet above.

- As in the other forums, check to see if a thread was made before you post it. If you make a thread that has already been made and is listed in the "Topics Already Posted" thread, then (1) the thread you created will be deleted and (2) you will receive a 1 day suspension.

- If you want to ask people what their favorite album is from a certain band, we prefer that you just post the question in the band's thread, as it is conversation.

- Don't make polls about which genre is better. There aren't enough choices, and there is no right answer to which genre is the best. Not to mention no one cares.

- Don't make polls comparing two bands unless there is an infamous feud between the two bands or the fans of one band generally dislike the other band. If you are unsure whether the thread is viable, please run it through a Smosh Moderator with a brief (one line) reason why it should be allowed.

- Flaming just for the fun of it is forbidden. Don't be like "OMG! THAT BAND SUCKS! YOU'RE SO STUPID!" We would prefer that you have an intellectual debate about a band.

- When posting a band/genre/musician/etc. thread please follow the following rules/guidelines. If the rules are not followed, the thread may be deleted and the poster warned/suspended.

BEFORE CREATING A NEW THREAD:
1) Check to see if the thread has already been created using the search function.
2a) If the thread exists, post your opinions there.
2b) If the thread's category isn't listed, please use the search function to see if the thread you were planning on making already exists. If i doesn't, post away.
3) Make sure the title of the band/genre/musician/etc. is clearly displayed in the thread title.
4) There really is no reason for a topic description, you can add one if you'd like.
5) Give you opinions of the band/genre/musician/etc. and say what you're favorite songs are, or why you like them, if you saw them live, etc.
6a) If what you're posting about is a band, then give at least one link to that band's music so other people who have not heard their music can have an opinion also. This is how discussion is carried out with everyone.
6b) If the thread is about a musician/singer post a link to some music they have done. Or if they were in multiple bands, post some of those.
6c) If it's a genre thread, give some examples of bands that you like/dislike of that genre.
7) Good Job! You've actually read all the rules!

By following these rules you will make a forum about one of the greatest things in the world, into one of the greatest forums on smosh.[/spoiler]

Fred's SOTD FAQ:

[spoiler]First off, some quick FAQ/QA type of thing.


*What is SOTD?
*Why not SOTW?
*YOUR MUSIC SUCKS
*Can i send you PMs of songs?
*You hated on my favorite band, im going to start an argument.
*Im going to spam you for being a moron
(more will be added when they come up, or if i think of more)



What is SOTD

SOTD (Song of the Day) is going to be a thing i do, where i find songs that i happen to like. If
i like a song enough, it will be dubbed "SOTD". Though it may not be on a daily basis (maybe 2 in a row sometimes) it will be might be once a week. or if i really havnt cared for much music for a while, itll be once a month

ill make a thread, but not more than 1 a day, and post a link to song, in one way or form (ill try to make them download-able)
Ill say why i liked the song, talk about it ( just to fill up space) and rant about some other bands' songs that i completely disliked

Why not SOTW? (song of the week)

Because SOTW was already taken by "sig of the week"

"UR MUSIC IS TEH SUXXORZ"

Deal with it, i dont like half the metal, screamo emo shit you listen to, but i dont complain.
Besides, im not trying to force you to listen to it, im only giving my thoughts. i think itll be fun
for you guys and I if i do this, and expand each others musical knowledge and tastes.

Can i send you a song to listen to?

yes and no.

DONT: do not PM me, i have a full PM box
DO: comment me
DONT: Post in the thread a name of a song
DO: send me a variety of songs
DONT: Send me country, or a song that has someone screaming into the microphone until its not understandable by the average ear

You said bad things about my favorite band! im going to cause trouble and argue an endless argument and spam!

YES! you can do that, just not in this thread, keep your shit out. This is my territory, if you dont like
riticism then never click this link. Im also requesting that Megadeath does surveillance on these threads.

BUT im not closed minded, if i ever say something that is incorrect comment me with the correct statement and some sort of proof. (example: i learned that maryln manson did not remove his lower ribs so he can give himself a blowjob)

"Your dumb, im going to say mean things to you in your comments"

a simple "block user" button can fix that, so save your time and anger for something else, like punching a baby.[/spoiler]

(Originally posted by Ashuku)

(But later edited by deademery)

(and again by dusty)

(And now redone by Megadeth53)

(later edited by kristandex- fixed some links and coding)

(further edited by dusty)

(once again edited by kristandex)

(another rule that surely everyone will read and obey added by Megadeth53)

(Frowned upon by the aki'aagi'i tribe in Senegal, Africa.)

("banned threads" rule added by Megadeth53)

(Fred's FAQ added by Megadeth53)

(Sexually abused by Gary Coleman)
rainydaze
this needed to be posted sooner. glad to see it up though
Xepher
Very Understandable.
cracker25
Well done someone set a standard.
ice
QUOTE(dusty @ Sep. 24, 2006. 06:04 PM) [snapback]3424[/snapback]

There will be specific guidelines for this forum that all must follow.


- You're allowed to make a thread about any band you want that doesnt already have its own thread, as long as you provide a good foundation for discussion in this thread. For example, we do not want threads simply stating that "Kidz Bop Vol. 9 is the best band ever", or "Tupac sucks". These types of threads obviously do not provide a good foundation for discussion, and will be closed if made. And no, you aren't better than anyone for knowing about a band that we didn't, nor are you better than anyone for knowing about a band longer than somone else. Use this as an example of a good thread about a band.

- Also, don't make a thread simply asking if people like a certain band. A thread with this question will result in people saying, "Yeah, I like them" or "No, I don't" which really isn't a discussion at all.

- It is highly encouraged to spread the word of local, or lesser-known bands, as much as possible, but please refer to the bullet above.

- As in the other forums, check to see if a thread was made before you post it. If you make a thread that has already been made, it too will be closed.

- Don't make polls about which genre is better. There arent enough choices, and there is no right answer to which genre is the best. Not to mention no one cares.



By following these rules you will make a forum about one of the greatest things in the world, into one of the greatest forums on smosh.


(Originally posted by Ashuku)



thank god someone toldtheppls what they needed to hear :lol:
_eyelash_wish_
thanks
Starlitangel13
That's reasonable.
RogueSkaterX
Vary good guidelines!!

smile.gif
Skittlez
goddamn..to think i made a team totally comitted to breaking the last rule...
Megadeth53
QUOTE(Skittlez @ Feb. 16, 2007. 07:37 PM) [snapback]186520[/snapback]

goddamn..to think i made a team totally comitted to breaking the last rule...


Actually that came up after TOBFT was formed.
Skittlez
so...we caused that rule to be brought up pretty much?


..still glad i disbanded though
deademery
UPDATED!

Updated again (2/28/07)
Iona
The date's written in the american format mm/dd/yy rather than the British way dd/mm/yy. It confused me.

/spam
deademery
QUOTE(Iona @ Mar. 3, 2007. 10:37 AM) [snapback]212527[/snapback]

The date's written in the american format mm/dd/yy rather than the British way dd/mm/yy. It confused me.

/spam


that might be because we're based in the US. and not just in the US. but in the capitol of the best state in the US. tongue.gif
ngard
QUOTE(deademery @ Mar. 3, 2007. 09:45 PM) [snapback]213634[/snapback]

QUOTE(Iona @ Mar. 3, 2007. 10:37 AM) [snapback]212527[/snapback]

The date's written in the american format mm/dd/yy rather than the British way dd/mm/yy. It confused me.

/spam


that might be because we're based in the US. and not just in the US. but in the capitol of the best state in the US. tongue.gif

I didn't know you guys were in Boston.
deademery
QUOTE(ngard @ Mar. 10, 2007. 10:43 AM) [snapback]225733[/snapback]

QUOTE(deademery @ Mar. 3, 2007. 09:45 PM) [snapback]213634[/snapback]

QUOTE(Iona @ Mar. 3, 2007. 10:37 AM) [snapback]212527[/snapback]

The date's written in the american format mm/dd/yy rather than the British way dd/mm/yy. It confused me.

/spam


that might be because we're based in the US. and not just in the US. but in the capitol of the best state in the US. tongue.gif

I didn't know you guys were in Boston.


everybody knows california is the best state. quit living in denial.

smoshgod
california rocks out loud
fuck texas
ngard
QUOTE(deademery @ Mar. 10, 2007. 09:37 PM) [snapback]226619[/snapback]

QUOTE(ngard @ Mar. 10, 2007. 10:43 AM) [snapback]225733[/snapback]

QUOTE(deademery @ Mar. 3, 2007. 09:45 PM) [snapback]213634[/snapback]

QUOTE(Iona @ Mar. 3, 2007. 10:37 AM) [snapback]212527[/snapback]

The date's written in the american format mm/dd/yy rather than the British way dd/mm/yy. It confused me.

/spam


that might be because we're based in the US. and not just in the US. but in the capitol of the best state in the US. tongue.gif

I didn't know you guys were in Boston.


everybody knows california is the best state. quit living in denial.

If it's the best state where were was California when the Revolutionary War was going on?

QUOTE(smoshgod @ Mar. 10, 2007. 09:39 PM) [snapback]226622[/snapback]

california rocks out loud
fuck texas

Are you trying to be funny or do you just not know where Boston is?
Sharpndt00thbrsh
Glad to finally see this posted...
spacemole
I thought things like this were normally locked?
Iona
I imagine that this is open so that people can suggest alterations to the rules or query anything that they don't understand.
dusty
QUOTE(Iona @ Apr. 27, 2007. 06:18 PM) [snapback]316251[/snapback]

I imagine that this is open so that people can suggest alterations to the rules or query anything that they don't understand.

correct. There's no harm in people replying to this thread, especially when there are additional questions and comments or whatever.
spence3020
do we need to tell u when we made a thread for a band to add it to the list? cuz i made a thread for the Pete & Mike band

p.s. im too lazy to check but every forum needs one of these guidelines if they dont already. they are very helpful thanks dusty
dusty
QUOTE(spence3020 @ May. 6, 2007. 02:23 PM) [snapback]333296[/snapback]

do we need to tell u when we made a thread for a band to add it to the list? cuz i made a thread for the Pete & Mike band

p.s. im too lazy to check but every forum needs one of these guidelines if they dont already. they are very helpful thanks dusty

well thanks, although it was Ashuku who wrote up the rules.. I just posted them. And I think that might be agood idea or something, I don't know, because Deademery is the one who wanted to make the list in the first place, so he should be the one maintaining it....
indecline
Add Ratatat.

In the "R" section.
spence3020
QUOTE(dusty @ May. 6, 2007. 11:25 PM) [snapback]334411[/snapback]

QUOTE(spence3020 @ May. 6, 2007. 02:23 PM) [snapback]333296[/snapback]

do we need to tell u when we made a thread for a band to add it to the list? cuz i made a thread for the Pete & Mike band

p.s. im too lazy to check but every forum needs one of these guidelines if they dont already. they are very helpful thanks dusty

well thanks, although it was Ashuku who wrote up the rules.. I just posted them. And I think that might be agood idea or something, I don't know, because Deademery is the one who wanted to make the list in the first place, so he should be the one maintaining it....

ok shoud i comment him or something?
Kristandex
QUOTE(spence3020 @ May. 7, 2007. 03:16 PM) [snapback]335237[/snapback]

QUOTE(dusty @ May. 6, 2007. 11:25 PM) [snapback]334411[/snapback]

QUOTE(spence3020 @ May. 6, 2007. 02:23 PM) [snapback]333296[/snapback]

do we need to tell u when we made a thread for a band to add it to the list? cuz i made a thread for the Pete & Mike band

p.s. im too lazy to check but every forum needs one of these guidelines if they dont already. they are very helpful thanks dusty

well thanks, although it was Ashuku who wrote up the rules.. I just posted them. And I think that might be agood idea or something, I don't know, because Deademery is the one who wanted to make the list in the first place, so he should be the one maintaining it....

ok shoud i comment him or something?

He's on Smosh break right now.
spence3020
^ok then
Skittlez
QUOTE(dusty @ May. 6, 2007. 11:25 PM) [snapback]334411[/snapback]

QUOTE(spence3020 @ May. 6, 2007. 02:23 PM) [snapback]333296[/snapback]

do we need to tell u when we made a thread for a band to add it to the list? cuz i made a thread for the Pete & Mike band

p.s. im too lazy to check but every forum needs one of these guidelines if they dont already. they are very helpful thanks dusty

well thanks, although it was Ashuku who wrote up the rules.. I just posted them. And I think that might be agood idea or something, I don't know, because Deademery is the one who wanted to make the list in the first place, so he should be the one maintaining it....

...He's been gone for ages though
Megadeth53
QUOTE(Skittlez @ May. 13, 2007. 08:36 PM) [snapback]347182[/snapback]

QUOTE(dusty @ May. 6, 2007. 11:25 PM) [snapback]334411[/snapback]

QUOTE(spence3020 @ May. 6, 2007. 02:23 PM) [snapback]333296[/snapback]

do we need to tell u when we made a thread for a band to add it to the list? cuz i made a thread for the Pete & Mike band

p.s. im too lazy to check but every forum needs one of these guidelines if they dont already. they are very helpful thanks dusty

well thanks, although it was Ashuku who wrote up the rules.. I just posted them. And I think that might be agood idea or something, I don't know, because Deademery is the one who wanted to make the list in the first place, so he should be the one maintaining it....

...He's been gone for ages though

Who cares? I think the music discussion is better off without mods anyways.
Kristandex
QUOTE(Megadeth53 @ May. 15, 2007. 12:56 AM) [snapback]348919[/snapback]

QUOTE(Skittlez @ May. 13, 2007. 08:36 PM) [snapback]347182[/snapback]

QUOTE(dusty @ May. 6, 2007. 11:25 PM) [snapback]334411[/snapback]

QUOTE(spence3020 @ May. 6, 2007. 02:23 PM) [snapback]333296[/snapback]

do we need to tell u when we made a thread for a band to add it to the list? cuz i made a thread for the Pete & Mike band

p.s. im too lazy to check but every forum needs one of these guidelines if they dont already. they are very helpful thanks dusty

well thanks, although it was Ashuku who wrote up the rules.. I just posted them. And I think that might be agood idea or something, I don't know, because Deademery is the one who wanted to make the list in the first place, so he should be the one maintaining it....

...He's been gone for ages though

Who cares? I think the music discussion is better off without mods anyways.

Well, we might as well delete it..
Megadeth53
QUOTE(kristinlovesSMOSHx3 @ May. 15, 2007. 08:32 PM) [snapback]350618[/snapback]

QUOTE(Megadeth53 @ May. 15, 2007. 12:56 AM) [snapback]348919[/snapback]

QUOTE(Skittlez @ May. 13, 2007. 08:36 PM) [snapback]347182[/snapback]

QUOTE(dusty @ May. 6, 2007. 11:25 PM) [snapback]334411[/snapback]

QUOTE(spence3020 @ May. 6, 2007. 02:23 PM) [snapback]333296[/snapback]

do we need to tell u when we made a thread for a band to add it to the list? cuz i made a thread for the Pete & Mike band

p.s. im too lazy to check but every forum needs one of these guidelines if they dont already. they are very helpful thanks dusty

well thanks, although it was Ashuku who wrote up the rules.. I just posted them. And I think that might be agood idea or something, I don't know, because Deademery is the one who wanted to make the list in the first place, so he should be the one maintaining it....

...He's been gone for ages though

Who cares? I think the music discussion is better off without mods anyways.

Well, we might as well delete it..

It's not like anyone looks at it before they run off and make another "Minutes to Midnight pwnzorz!!!" thread.
dusty
ok, updated the rules eh. And I wasn't really on with the "list" idea of deademery's anyway. If no one is going to maintain it, then there is no point to it.
rainydaze
I like the added rules, but still, most people arn't gonna read them first
donkeypunch
god newbies must be forced to read this first
greendayrulestce
QUOTE(donkeypunch @ Jun. 6, 2007. 12:38 PM) [snapback]392507[/snapback]

god newbies must be forced to read this first


They never read it first, if they do, it's the exception, (I didn't, but I have common sense and read it pretty soon into actually using the forums).
sgt_andrew
ok. . . .
Megadeth53
yey for dusty closing like 8 threads.

yay!!!!111!!
iLuvRyroXO
Great!
Iona
As no one ever reads these rules and no one ever seems to post links to bands songs/sites maybe you should be more lenient with that rule and just post asking people to add links, otherwise a ton of threads that besides that fact would be valid are going to get shut down. Just my thoughts.
Megadeth53
QUOTE(Iona @ Jul. 19, 2007. 08:42 AM) [snapback]472302[/snapback]

As no one ever reads these rules and no one ever seems to post links to bands songs/sites maybe you should be more lenient with that rule and just post asking people to add links, otherwise a ton of threads that besides that fact would be valid are going to get shut down. Just my thoughts.

For the record, that wasn't the only reason some threads got closed. But what you say kinda makes sense...
Iona
Yeah I know it wasn't but I thought that you saying that in most of the threads that you closed highlighted the fact that it is a pretty redundant rule.
daneisawesome
no one reads first
Megadeth53
It's become apparent that there is no way to get people to read the rules at all...

So, I need to find an alternative. I was thinking I could pin an example thread to see if people looked at that.

But I'm open to suggestions.
Iona
On old smosh the poetry thread was pinned as an example of a good thread. Maybe you could keep a real thread pinned that's promoting good discussion etc. and to keep it fair genre wise you could just alternate it on a weekly/fortnightly basis? That way people may try and make better posts to see their fave band's thread pinned (alternately they might not give a fuck).

I like that the forum's getting cleaned up smile.gif
Megadeth53
Alright Iona, sounds like a good idea. I'll get on that today.
\m./MaGGoT\.m/
QUOTE(Megadeth53 @ Jul. 19, 2007. 12:04 PM) [snapback]472356[/snapback]

It's become apparent that there is no way to get people to read the rules at all...

So, I need to find an alternative. I was thinking I could pin an example thread to see if people looked at that.

But I'm open to suggestions.


Maybe we should make the title more threatening, like "Fucking read this before I ban your skronny ass."

But in all seriousness, I think we need to make something that you need a certain post count and been a member for a certain amount of time before you can make a thread.
rainydaze
anywho, I like Iona's idea
_eyelash_wish_
anyways, I like Iona's idea as well.
Megadeth53
DONT YOU DARE SPAM MY THREADS BIITCH!!!!!!111!!!

EDIT: Dealt with the spammer. Those of you who quoted him, I just edited the quote and whatever you said about him out. And I just deleted what maggot said and the original post. Discussion in this thread needs to be kept on track, not have everyone quoting some retard.

Suggestions for additional rules are more than welcome.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.