QUOTE(NUBS @ Nov. 19, 2007. 03:33 AM) [snapback]679053[/snapback]
QUOTE(JaGuAr3529 @ Nov. 18, 2007. 06:58 PM) [snapback]678897[/snapback]
You're absolutely right, and it should appeal to only one decent sigmaker. The smallest possible audience should always be the goal, I say. Mass appeal is overrated.
So one week didn't appeal to everyone. Big deal. You act as though SOTW can never work again.
I certainly do
not act that way. In fact, I'm confident that SOTW will continue for weeks and weeks, despite coming off its worst week in history.
QUOTE(Gripster2000 @ Nov. 19, 2007. 04:27 AM) [snapback]679106[/snapback]
Not enough people entered, but I found the theme to be much more interesting than "flowers" or something like that. Our bad. I'm sure there will 60 more sig of the weeks that will be perfect for Jaguar, sophiebro and Kristan once again.
Not enough people entered because the theme was horrible, and most everyone knew that it would fail. And it
did fail, plain and simple.
Once again, this dispute is not about what's best for me, sophiebro, Kristan, NUBS, you, or any
one else; this is about what's best for SOTW. In a sigmaking sense, we shouldn't have a theme that
only appeals to me, just as we shouldn't have allowed a theme that, for the most part,
only appealed to NUBS. It would, and did last week, defeat the entire purpose of SOTW.