Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: books vs movies what is the best?
Smosh Forums > General > General Discussion
Pages: 1, 2
koko432
i think books are better than movies
they are more fun and interesting
ScrapeWisdom
Fight Club was a better book than movie.
koko432
QUOTE(ScrapeWisdom @ Oct. 12, 2008. 03:06 PM) [snapback]1256433[/snapback]

Fight Club was a better book than movie.

thats so true
A7X_BananaNose_A7X
It depends

If ur lazy movie
if not, the book because u experience more
JackMehoff
QUOTE(ScrapeWisdom @ Oct. 12, 2008. 07:06 PM) [snapback]1256433[/snapback]

Fight Club was a better book than movie.
Mostly for the end fight.
[spoiler]He bit his own tongue off, come on.[/spoiler]
Amandaswims
Books are usually better.
FallOutGoddess
im reading "The Lovely Bones" by Alice Sebold at the moment, and im super excited for the movie to come out!! tongue.gif This is related to the discussion because I don't know how the movie will ever be as good as the book since in the book you see the thoughts and feelings of the characters, whereas in the movies you kinda have to piece it together.
carpe-diem
I like books more!
Don't get me wrong. I love movies, but books are just better because you get to know the characters more. You get to know the thoughts and emotions of the characters.
Crazygranny
Depends what book or movie it is. Most books are better than movies, because they can include more ideas and stuff that movies cant. Also movies most of the time are based of books, and they drop out parts of the books. I would say that movies are better for visualization, but if you really want to know what is going on, go grab a good book. That is why most of the time I read the book before I go see the movie. smile.gif
WhiteStripes14
Movies. I just really despise reading.
dynamint
books make u more creative, maybe because u imagine everything.
but it depends on the point of view.


i like both.
EcoEclipse
I'd rather read the books, because sometimes the movies can be really fucked up to hell.

Example: The Eragon movie.
Shayla15
I don't mind when books are turned into movies as long as they don't completely ruin the story and fuck up the plot, miss the point, etc. etc...
poketron
Watching a movie then reading a book is a different experience than reading the book then watching the movie.
If you watch the movie first it can be a lot more interesting, since while you're reading the book, you'll think about a lot of the differences.
But reading the book first can get you more hyped up and wondering what differences there are before you see the movie.
costa-k
generally books but Shawshank redemption made a better movie
julialovessmosh
usually books because the movie is usually never like you thought the book was like. (that sentence made no sense but whatever :p)
Angiez_m
I would like to say books.. but I don't like reading.. so..
I'm just so impacient I can't read because I try to jump all the description and stuff I don't fucking care.. and it's all a mess so I prefer movies.
adrisk8ergurl
Books, then movies for me.
Girlie92
i actually really like books because they can go anywhere and they can be very interesting if you choose the right book for you. i love movies too.
but i will have to say books are better, most of the time they inspire movies.
brittybert
BOTH! If a movie and a book asked me to marry them, instead of choosing between the two, it would be a polygamous relationship. Ok no, gross, that was a joke.
Jessicaax
depends.
example : twilight the movie looks/sounds better then the book.
&
gossip girl, the book was more interesting then the shows. but they' k.
lalaloosurxx
Harry Potter book > HP Movies
Even though the movies are pretty good.

But as for other books, I don't know.
ChrispyDoggy
The Bible.
Khristophoros
i prefer books. in them, superman can actually fly. in movies they need special effects
TTTaxiCab
Movie def Movie if you read the book it gets you confused and stuff
Movie explains and shows stuff like the people then you know what they look like
lalaloosurxx
QUOTE(TTTaxiCab @ Oct. 12, 2008. 09:46 PM) [snapback]1257022[/snapback]

Movie def Movie if you read the book it gets you confused and stuff
Movie explains and shows stuff like the people then you know what they look like

Not if you know how to read.
Usually books explain what their characters look like.
Khristophoros
QUOTE(TTTaxiCab @ Oct. 12, 2008. 10:46 PM) [snapback]1257022[/snapback]

Movie def Movie if you read the book it gets you confused and stuff
Movie explains and shows stuff like the people then you know what they look like

no offense but that made u sound soooooo stupid
sorry blink.gif
ak_samoan14
well books r more detailed
but most people watch the movies either kuzz they want a easier way to find it out or they dont like to read the books
Khristophoros
or some people hav a.d.d. which makes it really hard to read
i hav a.d.d. and i can only read for about 20 minutes then take
a 5 minute break
ungrantedxwish
Books forsure, with the exception of Nicholas Sparks who is a shitty writer yet has pretty good plot ideas so the movies usually turn out better since you don't have to read his terrible descriptions.
ss140561
Books..

With books you can imagine what you want to imagine with the info given..

and with movies its just there.. no imagination needed...

Books are so much fun.. haha
kalhysha
"the movies are just an illustration for the book."
that's what i think

tetris
QUOTE(koko432 @ Oct. 12, 2008. 06:06 PM) [snapback]1256436[/snapback]

QUOTE(ScrapeWisdom @ Oct. 12, 2008. 03:06 PM) [snapback]1256433[/snapback]

Fight Club was a better book than movie.

thats so true


I have a feeling you have no idea what your talking about.
Sock_Puppet
They're both as good as eachover depending on the situation.
apricotalot
i agree with whoever said that the stuff aboout Eragon, the book was great but the movie sucked. i hope they don't skrew up the twilight movie i mean i swear to god if they do i will send them all very angry emails!!!

also i think we should be friends.
gabie123
i love to read but books are too much work, its easier to see the movie and you also get a better understanding of the story if you see the movie.

QUOTE(apricotalot @ Oct. 13, 2008. 10:10 AM) [snapback]1257407[/snapback]

i agree with whoever said that the stuff aboout Eragon, the book was great but the movie sucked. i hope they don't skrew up the twilight movie i mean i swear to god if they do i will send them all very angry emails!!!

also i think we should be friends.

they will screw up the twilight movie.
twilight is a retard.
i like the series of the "uglies" "pretties" and "specials" better
necrophrenic
I couldn't pick, they're both wonderful
babypuncher23
idk i hardly read. but when i read the book is uasually better
mia95
Movies are usually better.
jowbr
it depends...i read the davinci code and i looooved the book, but when i watched the movie, i thought that was not as cool as the book...buuuuuuut about brazilian literature, the movies are better...brazilian literature sucks Oo i hate that books and i do prefere the movies =D
N_2_the_A_2_the_IMA
Movies because reading is boring.
LESLIEDAWG
Isnt there already a thread?

gah,whatever..
hmm, books.
it's bettar.
greekgeek2008
books are better
movies usually change the story a little.
but id rather watch a movie, then read a book.
MavericksFan4455
Movies.
koko432
QUOTE(Jessicaax @ Oct. 12, 2008. 07:33 PM) [snapback]1256888[/snapback]

depends.
example : twilight the movie looks/sounds better then the book.
&
gossip girl, the book was more interesting then the shows. but they' k.

how can you say that!!!
thats the best book ever!!! so god
MisterMarty
Books by far.
JackMehoff
I can't wait to see how the Watchmen movie turns out.
Although, I'm quite certain it won't be as good as the graphic novel.
Magical_Trevor
QUOTE(EcoEclipse @ Oct. 12, 2008. 04:26 PM) [snapback]1256469[/snapback]

I'd rather read the books, because sometimes the movies can be really fucked up to hell.

Example: The Eragon movie.


Example: The chronicles of narnia
JMSTER109
It kinda depends
Shelbieee
Most books are better.
'Cept fer Harry Potter. : D
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.