I just noticed that Anthony always played the girl roles in their earlier videos, and now Ian does. Don't get me wrong, they are both hilarious. I think Anthony is a funnier girl though. Not saying that he looks like a girl or anything lol Seeing him in a skirt makes me laugh. Who's better at playing a girl? Anthony or Ian?

Anthony's good but I'm gonna say Ian on this one.

ian

i have to say anthony hands down!!

Ian.

I think Ians pretty funny, but Anthony was hilarious in the Hardcore Max vid.

I think I'm always the obviously manly girl with a man's voice, and Ian is the motherly girl with a girl voice. I don't know that, that;s just how thing usually end up working out.

Anthony and Ian should be both females in a future video and go shopping or something.

Anthony trained under me in the art of being a girl by going out with me!

LAWL and then I cheated on him with Ian so it's evenly matched

ian is a better girl fer sure lol
although anthonys great too

yeah thats a great idea u should tell them that

anthony looks alot funnier as a girl and its entertaining, but ian is better at the voice and the acting lol

they both play two different types of girls so its kinda hard to day, but anthony had the moves down in hardcore max

Anthony looks a lot funnier but Ian acts better and funnier.

i'd say ian

Haha, well, let's see here.

Anthony looks pretty hilarious as a girl in 'Hardcore Max.'
But I think Ian wins overall.
He's much better with voice/acting, etc., and I think he's been a girl more than Anthony has.

He's been Ian's Mom, Anthony's Mom, and "Emily" from 'Anthony gets a haircut,' I'm pretty sure. Anthony was looking at a picture of "Emily" during the video.

Well, anyways, yeahh....Ian owns.

Anthony

Yeah I think Ian is the best girl because he is basically the one who always is the girl right?

Anthony...he's got the legs.

My brother said Anthony was the ugliest tranny he ever saw (I wouldn't really go THAT far).

My opinion, Ian makes the better girl.

"Now give mommy a kiss!"

But, Anthony looked pretty funny in that "What Not To Do On A Date" video.

anthony was hilarious on hardcore max. both are equally good

shoot niggah, yous both be girls fo sho up da wall fo sho nigga right foo, mah nigga mofo.

I reckon Anthony is a better woman. Lol, he's not as manly as Ian (no offense).

anthony is funny as hell when he plays a girl ian is good but anthny is way better

sorry i forgot the o in anthony's name

I hav to say anthony, cos his face and body expressions are so funny! hahaha ian does hav a funnily retarded voice (no offence!!!) but anthony's is mor funny, cos (no offence agen) he sounds gay wen he puts a girl voice on LAWL

Haha. I would love to see that!!

I don't know both of them are good!

Great idea...

i think ian is a better girl. thats why when he first played a girl he always does after that. ya think about it.ya.

i think ian's a great mom, but anthony's a funny girl person, haha i can't choose!

Anthony looks better and sounds like one

I think Ian is the best to play a girl :b

I'd say Anthony because he has more feminine features. And he doesn't have a beard.

i have to say ian. he's voice is more feminine than anthony.

I personally think Ian plays a better girl. When he does it, it is just so hilarious. Like when anthony is trying to get his drivers license and Ian was the mother, I laughed my ass off, so I'm gonna have to go with Ian.

anthony in hardcore max lol

Well he dosen't say anything in that one, he just stands there looking pretty. I think maybe the looks, he could pass off more as a girl. Ian just looks so funny as a girl, but acting wise, Ian is great as a girl it really makes the videos funny.

I disagree. I find Anthony's voice resembling a female's more than I could for Ian.

I actually agree with you because if I would have to pick which one seemed more gay it would be Anthony because he does sound more girly than Ian. The way Ian does it though is really funny.

ian is funnier as a girl and when he tries to make the girl voice its HILARIOUS. and when he was a girl in license test he is so funny as a girl. but anthony is funny when he acts like a girl too. but he looks more manly and his voice isnt as high as ian's is when he plays a girl.

I don't think either of them appear gay...except for when they wear girl pants.

Anthony, hands down
But I would like to see them in a .. bitch fight maybe O_o

Anthony makes a better girl. just because he's more girlie than Ian anyway. it's pretty hot.

QUOTE(PillowMaster @ May. 16, 2007. 03:39 PM) [snapback]351920[/snapback]

I just noticed that Anthony always played the girl roles in their earlier videos, and now Ian does. Don't get me wrong, they are both hilarious. I think Anthony is a funnier girl though. Not saying that he looks like a girl or anything lol Seeing him in a skirt makes me laugh. Who's better at playing a girl? Anthony or Ian?

id definitely say Anthony plays a better girl, his most notable performance being in hardcore max- that was pretty convincing; whereas ian sometimes has a bit of a beard going on (eg driving test video) so he is diadvantaged by that.

Ian deffinately

ANOTHONNNNNNNYYY... ttly, u DO kno hes a transie?

Ian...

what the hell.. idk

Anthony I mean have u seen his legs in 'Hardcore Max' they are well toned

This clearly wins Ian, because looks better as a girl!!! Especially as Anthonys mom!!!

Anthony, he has a more fitting body type.

i would say that anthony plays a better girl.